About → Policies and guidelines → FA policies → FA criteria → FA nominations → Featured articles → FA reviews → Featured article reviews/Archive Links to archived featured article reviews.
Dates are adjusted to server time (UTC).
Please do not use templates for the link to the article.
Discussions started before November 2011 were removal discussions, so "successful" removals would be "failed" reconfirmations.
Removals
2005
- Andorian (3 January 2005 - 12 January 2005, Success)
- James T. Kirk (13 January 2005 - 5 March 2005, Success)
- Galaxy class (30 January 2005 - 20 March 2005, Success)
- Romulan (5 March 2005 - 20 March 2005, Success)
- Dominion (20 March 2005 - 11 April 2005, Success)
- The Doctor (27 April 2005 - 18 June 2005, Success)
- Sickbay (8 July 2005 - 3 August 2005, Failed)
- Emergence (episode) (13 July 2005 - 11 August 2005, Success)
- Call to Arms (episode) (5 September 2005 - 14 September 2005, Failed)
- Yesterday's Enterprise (episode) (15 September 2005 - 29 September 2005, Failed)
- Bolian (16 September 2005 - 25 October 2005, Failed)
- Grathon Tolar (26 September 2005 - 18 November 2005, Failed)
- Ethan Novakovich (5 October 2005 - 21 October 2005, Success)
- Klingon Empire (10 October 2005 - 21 October 2005, Success)
- Shinzon (3 December 2005 - 18 December 2005, Success)
2006
- Borg (13 January 2006 - 26 January 2006, Success)
- Khan Noonien Singh (17 January 2006 - 26 January 2006, Success)
- Excelsior class (23 January 2006 - 23 January 2006, Success)
- Observer Effect (episode) (14 May 2006 - 25 May 2006, Success)
- Miles O'Brien (25 July 2006 - 2 August 2006, Success)
- Janice Rand (9 December 2006 - 6 March 2007, Success)
2007
- Klingon (9 March 2007 - 20 March 2007, Success)
- Intrepid class (18 March 2007 - 29 March 2007, Success)
- All Good Things... (episode) (29 March 2007 - 7 July 2007, Failed)
- Starfleet ranks (mirror) (20 May 2007 - 7 July 2007, Success)
- United Federation of Planets (8 July 2007 - 15 July 2007, Success)
2008
- Sovereign class (30 January 2008 - 7 February 2008, Success)
- Maquis (3 February 2008 - 14 February 2008, Success)
- USS Equinox (4 June 2008 - 12 June 2008, Success)
- Borg-Species 8472 War (6 June 2008 - 16 June 2008, Success)
- Christopher Pike (20 July 2008 - 2 August 2008, Success)
- Good Shepherd (episode) (2 August 2008 - 6 August 2008, Withdrawn)
- Cardassian ATR-4107 (21 September 2008 - 18 November 2008, Failed)
- Grathon Tolar (23 September 2008 - 12 December 2008, Failed)
- Doomsday machine (25 September 2008 - 18 November 2008, Success)
2009
- In A Mirror, Darkly (episode) (15 April 2009 - 28 April 2009, Success)
- In A Mirror, Darkly, Part II (episode) (15 April 2009 - 28 April 2009, Success)
- A Matter of Perspective (episode) (14 September 2009 - 15 October 2009, Success)
- Tal Celes (12 December 2009 - 28 April 2010, Invalid)
2010
- Day of the Dove (episode) (28 April 2010 - 19 May 2010, Success)
- V'Ger (3 August 2010 - 19 October 2010, Success)
- Saucer separation (19 October 2010 - 15 November 2010, Withdrawn)
- Dukat (19 October 2010 - 11 November 2010, Success)
- Prototype (episode) (26 October 2010 - 16 November 2010, Success)
- Benjamin Sisko (29 October 2010 - 16 November 2010, Failed)
2011
- Telek R'Mor (2 February 2011 - 21 February 2011, Failed)
- Hope and Fear (episode) (23 February 2011 - 7 March 2011, Success)
- Xindi-Aquatic (3 March 2011 - 11 April 2011, Success)
- The Way of the Warrior (episode) (21 March 2011 - 11 April 2011, Failed)
- Dark Frontier (episode) (18 April 2011 - 28 April 2011, Success)
- Transporter (15 May 2011 - 27 August 2011, Success)
- Exocomp (19 August 2011 - 27 August 2011, Success)
- Tuvix (27 August 2011 - 1 December 2011, Failed)
Reconfirmations
2011
- The Way of the Warrior (episode) (1 December 2011 - 3 January 2012, Success)
- Telek R'Mor (1 December 2011 - 27 December 2011, Success)
- M-113 creature (5 December 2011 - 24 December 2011, Failed)
- Landru (5 December 2011 - 20 December 2011, Failed)
- Xindi incident (27 December 2011 - 17 January 2012, Success)
- Cutler (28 December 2011 - 30 January 2012, Success)
2012
- Thy'lek Shran (17 January 2012 - 3 February 2012, Success)
- Babel One (episode) (17 January 2012 - 3 February 2012, Failed)
- Schutzstaffel uniforms and insignia (3 February 2012 - 19 February 2012, Failed)
- Dominion War (19 February 2012 - 21 March 2012, Success)
- Ezri Dax (21 March 2012 - 7 April 2012, Success)
- Second Battle of Deep Space 9 (21 March 2012 - 7 April 2012, Success)
- Operation Return (21 March 2012 - 7 April 2012, Success)
- Battle of Cardassia (7 April 2012 - 1 May 2012, Success)
- Section 31 (7 April 2012 - 14 April 2012, Success)
- First Battle of Chin'toka (7 April 2012 - 1 May 2012, Success)
- Patricia Tallman (11 April 2012 - 1 May 2012, Success)
- Second Battle of Chin'toka (15 April 2012 - 1 May 2012, Failed)
- Klingon Civil War (1 May 2012 - 18 May 2012, Success)
- Xindi weapon (1 May 2012 - 18 May 2012, Success)
- Deep Space 9 (1 May 2012 - 18 May 2012, Success)
- James T. Kirk (8 May 2012 - 23 May 2012, Failed)
- Galaxy class (23 May 2012 - 6 June 2012, Success)
- Weyoun (23 May 2012 - 8 June 2012, Success)
- Yesterday's Enterprise (episode) (23 May 2012 - 22 June 2012, Failed)
- Sickbay (23 May 2012 - 6 June 2012, Failed)
- Bajoran wormhole (8 June - 23 June, Failed)
- Enterprise (NX-01) (8 June 2012 - 29 June 2012, Success)
- Battle of Wolf 359 (8 June 2012 - 12 August 2012, Failed)
- Battle of Sector 001 (23 June 2012 - 28 July 2012, Failed)
- Q (29 June 2012 - 9 September 2012, Failed)
- D'deridex class (9 September 2012 - 13 August 2013, Success)
2013
- Constitution class model (original) (17 September 2013 - 10 October 2013, Success)
- Constitution II class model (17 September 2013 - 10 October 2013, Success)
2014
- Martok (24 January 2014 - 13 February 2014, Success)
Reviews
2014
- Emissary of the Prophets (27 February 2014 - 13 March 2014, Removed)
- Nog (12 March 2014 - 19 March 2014, Upheld)
- Evolution (episode) (13 March 2014 - 23 March 2014, Upheld)
- Tom Morga (29 March 2014 - 19 April 2014, Upheld)
- Patricia Tallman (29 March 2014 - 19 April 2014, Upheld)
- Leslie Hoffman (29 March 2014 - 19 April 2014, Upheld)
2015
- Tal Celes (17 April 2015 - 3 May 2015, Upheld)
- Force field (23 April 2015 - 1 June 2015, Deadlocked)
- Boothby (26 April 2015 - 13 May 2015, Upheld)
- Star Trek design patents (4 May 2015 - 18 May 2015, Upheld)
- Ferengi (8 May 2015 - 26 June 2015, Upheld)
- Winn Adami (27 June 2015 - 13 July 2015, Upheld)
- Home Fires (16 October 2015 - 10 December 2015, Upheld)
- Age of Unreason (16 October 2015 - 10 December 2015, Upheld)
- Balance of Nature (16 October 2015 - 10 December 2015, Upheld)
- Breakdowns (eBook) (16 October 2015 - 10 December 2015, Upheld)
2016
- Dominion War (13 February 2016 - 1 March 2016, Removed)
- Leonard McCoy (30 March 2016 - 3 May 2016, Deadlocked)
- Christine Chapel (9 May 2016 - 10 June 2016, Deadlocked)
2017
- Breen (13 August 2017 - 4 October 2017, Upheld)
2018
- Assimilation (23 January 2018 - 8 February 2018, Upheld)
- Constitution class (7 February 2018 - 21 February 2018, Upheld)
- Ayala (8 February 2018 - 13 March 2018, Removed)
- Star Trek: Armada II (8 February 2018 - 1 March 2018, Deadlocked)
- Benjamin Sisko (17 March 2018 - 10 April 2018, Deadlocked)
- Christine Chapel (19 March 2018 - 6 April 2018, Upheld)
- Beverly Crusher (11 April 2018 - 28 May 2018, Removed)
- Damar (11 April 2018 - 28 May 2018, Removed)
- Deep Space 9 (20 August 2018 - 31 December 2018, Removed)
2019
- Weyoun (24 April 2019 - 26 June 2019, Removed)
- Christine Chapel (10 May 2019 - 15 October 2019, Removed)
2021
- Star Trek: Armada (9 March 2021 - 28 March 2022, Deadlocked)
2025
- Jean-Luc Picard (12 November 2025 - 2 December 2025, Removed)
- T'Pol (25 December 2025 - 19 January 2026, Deadlocked)